Top 7 ethical workplace pension providers in 2026

Written by Lori Campbell on 18th November 2026

If your business aims to make a positive difference, it’s worth asking whether your workplace pension reflects those same values.

Over time, your team’s pension savings can grow into a sizeable pot of money. That money could support renewable energy, social housing and businesses tackling environmental and social problems, or back industries that conflict with what your business stands for.

Most employees stay in the default: the investment option used when they don’t make their own choice. That makes the default’s approach especially important when choosing or reviewing a scheme.

These seven options offer different ways to bring sustainability into your workplace pension. We look at what they support, what they exclude and the charges worth checking.

How we use the Good Money Test

Our Good Money Test asks where your money goes, how transparent the provider is, whether it supports positive change, how it treats customers and whether its actions match its claims.

For workplace pensions, we also consider charges and whether members receive the ethical approach automatically or need to choose a different fund.

Our verdicts are editorial assessments, separate from Good Egg accreditation. Inclusion doesn’t mean every fund offered by a provider meets the same ethical standards. The order below isn’t a ranking of investment returns.

Ethical workplace pensions at a glance

ProviderWhat stands outGood Money Test
NestA clearly explained optional Ethical FundPass, with reservations
Smart PensionSustainability built into its main default growth fundPass, with reservations
Pangea Impact InvestmentsSustainable model portfolios designed for workplace defaultsPass
AvivaA choice of ethical and sustainable fundsPass
Royal LondonSustainable fund choices from a customer-owned providerPass
CushonAn accessible app and investment in environmental and social projectsPass, with reservations
People’s PensionNo shareholders and a tightly screened Ethical FundPass, with reservations

Nest

Good Money Test verdict: Pass, with reservations

Nest accepts employers of almost any size. Most members join its Retirement Date Funds, which adjust the investment mix as retirement approaches and apply responsible investment policies.

Members can choose the separate Ethical Fund for stricter screens. It also looks for investments supporting renewable energy infrastructure and low-carbon technologies.

What does it exclude? The optional Nest Ethical Fund avoids companies owning oil, gas or coal reserves, making or selling weapons, or breaching human rights and labour standards. It also excludes companies earning more than five per cent of revenue from other weapons components or goods and services customised for strategic military use. Further restrictions cover tobacco, alcohol, gambling, pornography, fur and cosmetics testing on animals.

Charges: Nest charges employers nothing. Members pay 1.8 per cent on new contributions and 0.3 per cent a year on their pension pot.

Watch out: The contribution fee takes £18 from every £1,000 paid in, before the annual charge. Transfers into Nest don’t attract it. The default isn’t fossil-fuel-free; staff must choose the Ethical Fund for its stricter screens.

Good for: Employers wanting broad access and a clearly explained ethical option, while weighing up the contribution fee.

Smart Pension

Good Money Test verdict: Pass, with reservations

Smart builds sustainability into its main default growth fund, the Smart Sustainable Growth Fund. This invests across different assets, including companies helping solve environmental and social challenges. Smart targets net zero by 2040 for its listed assets.

What does it exclude? Its responsible investment policy sets out manager exclusions covering controversial weapons, companies earning most of their revenue from coal mining, and breaches of UN principles on human rights, labour, the environment and corruption. The Sustainable Growth Fund also excludes companies earning more than five per cent of revenue from tobacco cultivation and production. It isn’t fossil-fuel-free and doesn’t exclude all arms manufacturers.

Members wanting stricter exclusions can choose the separate Smart Ethical and Climate Fund. Its underlying L&G index fund applies broader fossil fuel and tobacco screens, alongside controversial weapons and UN principles exclusions. Fossil fuel screens have activity and ownership thresholds; the weapons policy doesn’t exclude all arms companies.

Charges: Scheme and fund charges vary. Members may pay a fixed monthly fee alongside investment charges, and some employers also pay a monthly charge. Request a full quote.

Watch out: Fixed fees take a bigger share of small pots, especially after contributions stop. Smart says its monthly member fee doesn’t apply where combined savings with it are £100 or less.

Good for: Employers wanting sustainability in the default, with close attention to charges on smaller pots.

Pangea Impact Investments

Good Money Test verdict: Pass

Pangea builds sustainable workplace pension portfolios using Amundi index funds. Its Cautious, Core and Adventurous portfolios are designed for use as auto-enrolment defaults, bringing sustainable investing to employees who don’t actively choose their investments. The share funds favour companies better placed for the transition to a lower-carbon economy.

What does it exclude? The MSCI screening rules screen out controversial weapons, specified nuclear weapons involvement, tobacco and very severe environmental or social controversies. They exclude companies earning at least 10 per cent of revenue from specified oil and gas activities, or one per cent from thermal coal mining. Separate screens cover fossil fuel power generation and civilian firearms. Pangea says comparable exclusions apply to its bond investments, including in its lower-risk portfolio.

Charges: Pangea quotes an annual platform charge of 0.55 per cent on the first £50,000, falling in tiers for larger pots, plus portfolio costs of 0.16-0.18 per cent. It says there are no setup, contribution or transfer charges.

Watch out: The screens allow some fossil fuel exposure below their thresholds and don’t amount to a blanket conventional arms ban. Factsheets are available through the member portal; employers can request detailed holdings when assessing the scheme.

Good for: Businesses and charities wanting sustainability built into their default investment approach.

Aviva

Good Money Test verdict: Pass

Aviva offers ethical and sustainable investment choices alongside its mainstream workplace pension defaults.

Its defaults include My Future Focus and My Future, depending on the scheme. Members can choose optional Stewardship funds, which seek companies contributing to its Climate, Earth and People themes.

What does it exclude? The Stewardship policy excludes manufacturing of conventional and nuclear weapons, their components and support systems, alongside severe human rights and labour controversies. It excludes thermal coal and unconventional oil and gas production, but allows some conventional oil and gas exposure below declining revenue limits. The screens apply to company shares and bonds, with different treatment for cash, third-party funds and certain derivatives. They are separate from Aviva’s default policies.

Charges: Charges depend on the workplace scheme and funds selected. Request the full employer and member costs, including any additional charge for ethical options.

Watch out: Stewardship funds aren’t completely fossil-fuel-free. Their screens are separate from the default’s, so check which funds staff will actually use.

Good for: Employers wanting a mainstream provider with a choice of ethical funds.

Royal London

Good Money Test verdict: Pass

Royal London is customer-owned and offers a sustainable fund range covering shares, bonds and a mix of the two. The options have different levels of investment risk.

The sustainable funds assess companies’ environmental and social contribution alongside their financial prospects. The underlying UK funds carry the Sustainability Focus label.

Members can also choose RLS Sustainable Leaders or RLS Global Sustainable Equity for the share portion of its Governed Range portfolios.

What does it exclude? Royal London Asset Management’s sustainable approach avoids armaments manufacturers, tobacco manufacturers and fossil fuel extraction. It also assesses human rights and labour standards. Some energy companies moving towards renewables and businesses improving the safety or environmental impact of extraction can qualify, so this is not a blanket exclusion of every fossil fuel link. These criteria apply to the sustainable funds, rather than every Royal London pension investment.

Charges: Request the full scheme and fund charges. The two sustainable share fund substitutions above carry no extra substitution charge, but normal pension charges still apply.

Watch out: Switching the share portion doesn’t apply the sustainable fund’s criteria to every other investment in the portfolio.

Good for: Employers wanting a customer-owned provider with established sustainable fund choices.

Cushon

Good Money Test verdict: Pass, with reservations

Cushon combines a sustainability-focused pension with an app designed to make savings easier to understand and manage.

Its main default, the Cushon Sustainable Investment Strategy, invests in global shares and bonds, alongside projects such as renewable energy, social housing, forestry and clean technology.

What does it exclude? Within the default, its global equity fund excludes companies with verified ongoing involvement in controversial weapons, including nuclear weapons, and breaches of international standards covering human rights and labour. Other underlying funds have their own screens. The policy does not establish a blanket ban on all arms or fossil fuel investments across the default.

Charges: Cushon advertises no employer charge and member charges starting at 0.69 per cent a year, depending on investments. Existing scheme arrangements may differ.

Watch out: Compare the charges quoted for your workforce and check the exclusions. A sustainability-focused default isn’t necessarily fossil-fuel-free.

Good for: Employers who want staff to engage with their pension and understand what it helps finance.

People’s Pension

Good Money Test verdict: Pass, with reservations

People’s Pension has no shareholders, with profits going back into supporting members.

Most members use its Balanced investment profile, which changes the investment mix as retirement approaches. The provider says 80 per cent of members’ money is in climate-aware investments.

What does it exclude? Its optional Ethical Fund excludes fossil fuel producers and companies with fossil fuel-related revenue, alongside UN Global Compact breaches and very severe environmental or social controversies. Its weapons screens specify controversial weapons, nuclear weapons and civilian firearms, rather than a blanket ban on all military equipment. Other screens cover tobacco, alcohol, gambling, pornography, recreational cannabis, for-profit prisons and unsustainable palm oil, with revenue thresholds for some activities. The default has different, less extensive exclusions.

Charges: Members pay 0.5 per cent a year, with savings rewards on balances above £3,000, plus £6.50 annually on pots of £106.50 or more. Employers usually pay £500 plus VAT to join directly, with no ongoing employer fees. Setup is free through qualifying advisers and payroll services firms.

Watch out: The £6.50 fixed fee alone is equivalent to 1.3 per cent of a £500 pot, before the percentage charge. It takes a larger share of smaller savings, particularly when someone has left the scheme and stopped paying in. Members need to select the Ethical Fund to benefit from its stricter exclusions.

Good for: Employers attracted by its no-shareholder model and Ethical Fund, who also consider costs for staff with small pots.

What does the Mansion House Accord mean for your scheme?

Nest, Smart Pension, Aviva, Royal London, Cushon and People’s Pension have all signed the Mansion House Accord.

This voluntary agreement aims for at least 10 per cent of main defined contribution default funds to be in private markets by 2030, including at least five per cent of the total in UK private markets. Savers’ interests must still come first.

Private markets include unlisted businesses, property and infrastructure, which can include renewable energy and social housing. More UK investment doesn’t automatically mean a pension is more or less ethical.

Ask how new investments will be checked against the scheme’s environmental and social policies. If staff want stricter exclusions, compare the default with the specialist ethical options available. Signing the Accord alone isn’t a reason to switch funds.

Keep checking what the fund actually holds

A pension can keep the same name while its underlying investments change. A fund described as ESG, sustainable or ethical may still hold companies your business or employees would prefer to avoid.

When investments change, check whether their replacements follow the same exclusions and sustainability aims. Compare holdings alongside charges and returns.

Build this into your scheme review and ask how important changes will be explained to employees.

How to choose an ethical workplace pension

Start with the default. Ask what it invests in, what it excludes and whether those rules still apply as members approach retirement.

Be specific about weapons. Excluding controversial weapons can still leave conventional arms manufacturers in a fund. For fossil fuels, check whether the policy covers extraction, power generation and services. Human rights and workers’ rights deserve the same attention as climate targets.

Compare the full employer and member charges using both small and larger pots, including what someone pays after leaving your business. Then check payroll compatibility, employee support and how clearly the provider explains its investments.

If your scheme offers an optional ethical fund, help staff understand how to find it. Explain that the investment mix and risk level may differ from the default.

Frequently asked questions

What makes a workplace pension ethical?

Look at what the investments support and exclude, how the provider challenges companies and how openly it reports its holdings. Check the default separately from optional ethical funds.

Does an ethical workplace pension cost more?

Not necessarily. Compare employer fees, member charges and fund costs. Ask for examples showing the cost for staff with small pots, including those who stop contributing.

Is offering an optional ethical fund enough?

It gives staff a choice, but only those who select it will benefit from its approach. If sustainability is a priority for your business, pay particular attention to the default and make the alternatives easy to understand.

Should we change our existing pension scheme?

Start by asking your provider what it can offer and whether the current arrangement meets your team’s needs. Compare investments, charges, payroll requirements and support before deciding. An employer pension adviser can help assess the options and manage a change.

Can a fund’s ethical approach change?

Yes. Holdings, managers and exclusion policies can change. Review the latest documents and ask whether replacement funds follow the same standards.

This article is for information, not personal financial advice. Pension investments can fall as well as rise, and members could get back less than they invest. Charges and investment policies can change.

Don't miss the good stuff!

Sign up for the newest and best green money deals in your inbox every week